The Perplexity of Herod about Jesus

GOSPEL THOUGHTS*

*Ordinary Season:  Twenty Fifth Week : Thursday*

*Gospel : Lk 9:7-9*

*First Reading : Hg 1:1-8*

*Responsorial Psalm : Ps 149:1b-2, 3-4, 5-6a And 9b*

*The Perplexity of Herod about Jesus*

*1) Why was Herod perplexed?*

Herod Antipas' perplexity reveals a deep internal conflict. Here's why:

*A) Moral Conviction vs. Personal Desire:*

Herod knew John was "righteous and holy." His conscience was stirred by John's bold message, especially John's condemnation of Herod's unlawful marriage to Herodias (his brother's wife). 

He couldn't dismiss John easily because he sensed the truth in his words, yet he was unwilling to repent.

*B) Fear vs. Fascination:*

Herod feared John’s influence and perhaps divine judgment, yet he was fascinated by him. 

He liked listening to John, even though it left him confused and uncomfortable. 

That paradox—fear mixed with attraction—is the heart of his perplexity.

*C) Pressure from Others (Herodias):*

Herod was also torn because of Herodias, who hated John and wanted him dead. 

Herod kept John alive, but not out of courage—out of fear and hesitation. 

His perplexity was not just personal but political and relational.

*2) Reflections on Herod's Perplexity*

*A Portrait of a Divided Soul*

Herod is a tragic figure—a man who hears the truth, recognizes it at some level, but refuses to submit to it. 

His inner turmoil reflects what happens when the conscience is awakened, but the will remains rebellious.

*B) Truth Can Be Disturbing*

John's preaching cut through the illusions of Herod's life. 

This perplexity is what often happens when the truth confronts someone who is not ready to let go of sin or power. 

It's easier to silence the messenger than change the behavior.

*C) The Danger of Delay*

Herod listened "gladly," but never acted. He delayed repentance. 

Eventually, when pressured, he allowed John's execution to please others (Mark 6:26). 

His inaction led to moral collapse. Perplexity, left unresolved, can become hard-heartedness.

*D) Listening Isn't Enough*

Herod listened to John but never obeyed. 

This reminds us that exposure to truth doesn’t save a person—responding to it does. 

A heart that delights in the sound of truth but resists its demands is on dangerous ground.

*E) Conviction without Conversion*

Many today, like Herod, may feel convicted when they hear the Gospel or ethical truth. 

They may admire the messenger or appreciate the message, but unless that conviction leads to change, it ends up deepening their judgment.

*3) Final Thought*

Herod's perplexity is a mirror. 

It reflects the universal human tension between knowing what is right and wanting to do what is wrong. 

His story asks us:

What do we do with the truth when it unsettles us? 

Do we silence it, delay it, or surrender to it?

Perplexity can be the beginning of repentance—or the prelude to ruin

*Think about it*

*God bless you and your family. Praying for you and your dear ones*

*Fr Maxim DSouza*

*Jeppu Seminary*

*Mangalore*